Topic | Choose topic/s and define your search
Affiliations / Personalities
Date Range

PMW warns PA incitement still alive and well in JPost article

Jonah Mandel  |

PA religious affairs minister
condemns Itamar murders

by Jonah Mandel

Let’s make peace in the Holy Land, says Mahmoud Habbash; watchdog group: Don’t take such comments seriously.

The Palestinian Authority’s Minister of Religious Affairs Mahmoud Habbash on Thursday condemned last weekend’s murder of five Israelis in Itamar and insisted that the PA was acting to counter incitement against Jews.

“I say the same as [PA President Mahmoud] Abbas – this is a big crime against civilians in their homes, an inhuman crime,” he told The Jerusalem Post in a telephone interview.

“We are against such crimes from both sides, and against any murders, whether from the Palestinian or Israeli side. We want to see all the civilians living in peace in the Holy Land.”

Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu, in a Saturday night statement, linked the brutal stabbing to death of the sleeping family to incitement in the mosques and educational system in the PA. [...]

Abbas, too, condemned the murder, but denied that such incitement existed in the PA.

On Thursday, Habbash firmly rejected the notion that the PA allowed incitement, while noting that violent rhetoric aimed at Palestinians emanated from Jews as well and must be addressed.

“We are, from the beginning, against any bad incitement, not just inside the Palestinian Authority. This includes from schools, mosques and the media,” he said. [...]

When asked what he defined as incitement, Habbash said that... “We were asked to take part in the American committee established over 10 years ago to define what is and what is not incitement, not only on the PA side, but also the Israeli one, how to stop it, and move forward in cooperation. Until now the Israeli side refused to meet with the Palestinians for these discussions,” he said.

To Habbash, “if anyone encouraged hatred among the public, called to kill others, or to throw them out of their homeland – this would be considered bad incitement. If people are called animals – such as Muslims calling Jews children of monkeys – this is bad incitement, and we are against it. And the same applies to if a Jewish rabbi calls Palestinians snakes and animals.

“In such cases, we have to step in, whether it is in mosques, schools or holy places, to prevent imams and rabbis saying such things,” Habbash said. [...]

The committee to which Habbash was referring was a trilateral anti-incitement committee, composed of American, Israeli and Palestinian representatives, formed at the demand of Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu as part of the Wye River Memorandum.

While the committee met once a week in 1999, “nothing ever came out of it,” said Itamar Marcus, founder and director of Palestinian Media Watch, who was part of the Israeli team for the anti-incitement committee.

“Calling what goes on in the PA incitement would be understating the problem and its significance; talking about indoctrination, and seeing it as part of the ongoing war against Israel” would be more accurate, Marcus said on Thursday.

Marcus noted examples such as the fact that Abbas recently awarded $2,000 to the family of a terrorist who attacked IDF soldiers, and that a week before the Itamar killings, the PA-controlled television channel honored two people sitting in prisons, and referred to them as heroes – the woman who drove a suicide bomber to the Sbarro restaurant in Jerusalem, and the man who drove a suicide bomber to the capital’s Pat junction.

As for Habbash himself, Marcus said the minister had referred to the conflict with Israel on religious terms, calling it a Ribat, which in effect means that reconciliation is prohibited from a religious point of view.

“It’s a big mistake to take [what Abbas and Habbash say in] English seriously; they speak very differently in different languages every day,” Marcus said.